BHN Exclusive: Mass gift ban takes a beating from ACRE

IMG_1576_edited

Thursday’s inaugural meeting of the Association of Clinical Researchers and Educators drew a full house to the Bornstein Amphitheater at Brigham and Women’s Hospital.  Members of the group believe that disclosure rules and gift bans for doctors – like the one that just went into effect in Massachusetts –  are too strict.  The meeting program describes the issue this way:

Under mounting pressure from interest groups, the media, and select government officials, academic medical centers have begun adopting restrictive conflict of interest policies that often sever productive relationships between industry and physicians involved in clinical research and educational outreach.

(See this Globe story for  background on the topic or click on the “research integrity” category to the left. Critics of industry support for academic researchers say it creates to conflicts of interest. Supporters believe it encourages innovation. )

So, withportraits of notable BWH doctors looking down on them, researchers, lawmakers and industry reps made a lot of jokes about the corrupting influence of pens with drug company logos. A sampling of the speakers found that they ranged from measured and informative to shrill and angry.

This from a session on the Massachusetts gift ban, which prohibits drug and device companies from marketing products by courting doctors with high end meals, Red Sox tickets and four-star travel.

–State Representative Michael J. Rodrigues, vice chairman of the legislature’s Committee on Public Service, said doctors need to be more involved in fighting the laws like the state’s gift ban law.

“I was very happy with the support I got from industry. But throughout the debate I was wondering – where are the physicians. “

–Sarah Elisabeth Curi, a lawyer with the Mass Medical Society, explained the new law and said the law will focus on industry compliance, not doctors.

 “No physician in Massachusetts is going to be arrested for not complying with the law”

–Dr. Carey D. Kimmelstiel, head of clinical cardiology at the Tufts University School of Medicine talked about the benefits of having clinicians give industry-sponsored talks. Preparing the talk educates the speaker. He or she gets feedback and an audience of busy docs gets a quick update.

 Dr. Henry R. Black  Hypertension Division, New York University Medical Center, President, American Society of Hypertension :On Value of Collaboration to Medical Training Programs & Professional Associations

There were also a few supporters of conflict rules and gift bans in the crowd, including former NEJM editor Arnold Relman, who offered post meeting comments. The American Medical Student Association– a group worried about conflicts  of interest for industry-funded professors  – also sent a few people. Nitin Roper, a University of Connecticut medical student, had this to say about the meeting.

   

Finally, here are some other reports on ACRE and the meeting: Postscript,  The Carlat Psychiatry Blog and Policy and Medicine

 

Advertisements

8 Responses to “BHN Exclusive: Mass gift ban takes a beating from ACRE”

  1. News Round up and ethnic aging « Boston Boomer News Says:

    […] Wonk Review, a twice monthly digest of health blog postings. At the very end you’ll find a post from BBN’s sister blog, Boston Health […]

  2. Health Reform Gone Wild! « Boston Health News Says:

    […] a twice monthly digest of intelligent health blog postings. At the very end you’ll find my post on doctors fight gift band and conflicts of interest […]

  3. Harvard muzzles med students « Boston Health News Says:

    […] Fortunatly, this policy did not apply to the UConn student I interviewed at a recent conference on the topic. […]

  4. Lilly funds 60 Boston docs « Boston Health News Says:

    […] collaborations and relationships benefit patients and advance science.”  Also note BHN’s reporting from the meeting, which took place at Brigham and Women’s Hospital. […]

  5. Academics, industry, health reform and medical devices « Boston Health News Says:

    […] on academic/industry partnerships and explains new transparency rules in the Senate reform bill. Massachusetts has had a state law on this but it’s only been in effect for a few […]

  6. Mass dumps part of its pharma gift ban « Boston Health News Says:

    […] BHN Exclusive: Mass gift ban takes a beating from ACRE « Boston … Jul 24, 2009 … This from a session on the Massachusetts gift ban, which prohibits drug and device …. Stossel, conflicts and the new… […]

  7. In Massachusetts, lighter pharma gift ban may = higher costs for consumers #HCR #mapoli « Boston Health News Says:

    […] BHN Exclusive: Mass gift ban takes a beating from ACRE « Boston … Jul 24, 2009 … This from a session on the Massachusetts gift ban, which prohibits drug and device …. Stossel, conflicts and the new… […]

  8. Former #NEJM editor Arnold Relman dies at 91 #pharma | Boston Health News Says:

    […] issues. Relman often commented on the influence of money on medicine. In 20o9,  he crashed the inaugural meeting of the Association of Clinical Researchers and Educators (ACRE) “an organization of medical […]


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: